_________

 

_________

 

 

archives

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Dismal Science

by Thomas Canfield

 


      The two parties stood on opposite sides of a stone obelisk that marked a local territorial boundary. They examined one another with open curiosity. Outside of Darwin, the linguist, none of the Earthmen had ever dealt with Diatoms before. They were in a remote corner of the star cluster and contacts with them had been few. Van Buren believed his was the first expedition of any real scope to pay them a visit. Previous missions had all been strictly scientific in nature.
      “All right, Darwin,” Van Buren turned to the linguist, “let’s get the ball rolling here. Is there any sort of ceremonial greeting or ritual we have to go through?”
      “It doesn’t appear so.” Darwin shrugged his shoulders. “Apparently the Diatoms don’t go in for such things.”
      “Good,” Van Buren exclaimed. That was a relief. He had been on other expeditions where three-quarters of the time was wasted indulging the natives in some fool ritual or other. It was a good sign that the Diatoms didn’t go in for such nonsense. Van Buren examined the aliens without appearing to do so. They were squat, gnome-like creatures, heavy-boned and slow in their movements. Their skin had a peculiar marbled quality to it, blue and pale grey. They were ugly, certainly, but not aggressively so.
      “Which one is in charge?” Van Buren said to the linguist. “Who’s the one we’re dealing with?”
      “That one, with the pattern of red dye on his face.” Darwin nodded discreetly. “The dye represents a symbol of his authority. The others are bound by some form of allegiance. I haven’t wholly figured out their social system as yet. But he’s the one running the show, no doubt about that.”
      Van Buren nodded. This was another favorable development. He had dealt with other alien cultures where nobody was in charge, where a kind of socialist equality pervaded the entire society: every individual was every other individual’s equal. It was impossible to get anything done in such a case. The natives would debate endlessly and the more they debated the further any chances of reaching a decision receded into the distance.
      “O.K. Tell him . . .” Van Buren paused, looked at the Diatom. “What is his name by the way?”
The linguist addressed a question to the head Diatom in the harsh, guttural tongue of the natives. “As far as I can make out,” Darwin pursed his lips, “an approximate English rendering would be Ibid.”
      “Ibid?” Van Buren repeated doubtfully. “You’re sure?”
      “As I said,” the linguist gave a small, tight smile, “that would be an approximate rendering. The correlation between the two tongues is not at all exact.”
      Van Buren made a face. “Ibid, then. Tell Ibid that we come in peace and that we hope to discover whether there might be some sort of goods they would be interested in trading. Tell him that we have many useful and intriguing items which they could not get or manufacture for themselves. We can arrange to extend a line of credit initially to help with any purchases, if they so desire. Of course, our sole intent in any transaction is to establish a relationship that would mutually benefit both parties,” Van Buren added.
      “Of course,” Darwin repeated, his face studiously blank. He turned to the Diatom, translated. The Diatom scowled. He scratched his ear then spat out a quick stream of guttural noises that sounded like abuse.
      “The Diatom wishes to know,” Darwin translated, “what exactly a line of credit consists of.”
      Van Buren smiled. One of the principal objects of the initial negotiations was to discover just how financially astute members of the alien culture were. Those who were not well versed in the intricacies of finance, well, he would undertake to guide and instruct them. Naturally, in the exercise of this office, certain advantages would accrue to him.
      “A line of credit means that you could purchase an item without paying for it up front,” Van Buren explained. “The money would be repaid over a certain period of time, to be worked out in advance. Of course, interest would accumulate on that part of it still due and payable. In effect, we are loaning you the money.”
The Diatom barked something short and sharp. “Explain interest,” Darwin translated.
      Van Buren frowned. “That’s exactly how he said it – explain interest, like that?” Darwin nodded. “Is he attempting to be rude?”
      “I think that is simply the Diatom’s style,” the linguist suggested. “Blunt and direct. I wouldn’t attempt to read anything into it. Some peoples rely on circumlocution and subterfuge.” The linguist’s expression was now laced with irony. “Others don’t. The Diatoms apparently believe in saying just what they mean, without dressing it up for effect. I think we’ll have to take them as they are.”
      Van Buren shrugged. He turned to the Diatom. “Interest,” he said and paused, considering, “interest is the cost assessed for a service. In this case, a loan extended to a borrower. In technical terms it could be defined as the time value of money, projected into the future.” Van Buren smiled at the Diatom pleasantly. “It is a fairly simple concept, really.”
      The Diatom said something in a low tone. Van Buren turned to the linguist.
      “Uh, the Diatom says why would you go to all this trouble . . .” Darwin paused, shook his head. “No, trouble doesn’t really capture the essence of what he said. The word he used has much stronger overtones. There are certain scatological implications.” Darwin ran his fingers through his hair. “I’m afraid there isn’t an English equivalent.”
      “Yes, yes,” Van Buren brushed this aside, “just give me the gist of what he said. I don’t need an exact translation.”
      “He says, why go to this kind of trouble to complete a simple transaction.”
      Van Buren turned to the Diatom, speaking eagerly. “It would be totally wrong to regard this as trouble. If I left you with such an impression it is the fault of language barriers and does not in any sense reflect on the intrinsic merit of the idea. Advancing you the money is a financing technique which enables you to purchase something you would not otherwise be able to afford. It extends to you options which, were you to live solely within your means, would not be available to you.”
The Diatoms danced about in agitation when Darwin finished translating this. Some of Van Buren’s men adopted a defensive posture, letting their hands rest on the stocks of their weapons. These little parleys did not always end in an agreeable manner.
      The head Diatom strode back and forth, gesturing emphatically. Darwin translated.
      “He asks why he should wish to buy something he can not afford. If he can not afford it, plainly he is better off not buying it. It goes against . . . something. I don’t know what he’s saying. It would seem we have stumbled upon a fiscal conservative, Director.” A ghost of a smile hovered about Darwin’s lips.
      Van Buren threw up his hands in frustration. “Fiscal conservative? A financial illiterate is what he is. Doesn’t understand a thing. The simplest notion and he takes it and turns it on its head. What can you do with such imbeciles?”
      “Do you wish me to translate that?” Darwin inquired blandly.
      Van Buren threw him a black look. “Here,” he directed one of the men, “haul that box forward. Let’s show him what we’ve got to trade. Maybe something in there will catch his fancy. I think I know what’ll do it, too.”
      The man dragged the box forward, grunting. Van Buren opened it. He took out a large growth of fungus, held it up.
      “The mushrooms of Apogee,” he began his pitch. “Held to be a great delicacy by the epicures of several worlds. There’s nothing in any cuisine, anywhere, that compares with them. There is no diet they won’t either complement or enhance. In addition they possess certain medicinal qualities I’ll be happy to elaborate upon. And,” Van Buren smiled, winked lewdly, “they are accounted by many as the sole true aphrodisiac anywhere in the galaxy.” Van Buren extended the mushroom toward the head Diatom.
      Ibid hesitated, directed a subordinate to fetch the mushroom. He broke off a hunk of the fungus, sniffed at it. His face contorted wrathfully. “Shnaztek,” he pronounced and cast it aside in disgust.
      There was an ominous murmur from Van Buren’s men. The mushroom of Apogee was revered amongst them, held in such esteem that men were known to have killed to obtain it.
      “Easy,” Van Buren cautioned. He turned to the linguist. “What did he say?”
      “An expletive,” Darwin said. “A forceful and impolite expression of contempt. Roughly equivalent to our ‘This is shit’.” The men stirred in agitation, gripping their weapons.
      “Stand down, Van Buren ordered them. “Stand down, I said.” He shook his head. “They are savages, savages. Imagine anyone reacting as they have. Obviously, nothing we propose to offer will appeal to them. They haven’t obtained a level of culture sufficient to appreciate anything more sophisticated than nettles and fungo berries.” Darwin said nothing.
      “There is one thing,” Van Buren reflected. His eyes became dark, calculating. “Yes, we do have one item. I think . . .” He shot a glance at Darwin. he did not entirely trust the linguist. He was too much of an intellectual, his perspective was always too broad and sympathetic. His allegiance did not lie strictly with the success of the mission as it should but rather with some vague concept that embraced qualities of compassion and fairness. His training and disposition essentially left him unfit for a venture of this nature. But, of course, they could not function without him.
      “You and you!” Van Buren pointed to two of his men. “Go check on the cache of weapons. Bring me a sixty angstrom laser pistol and a thermopile resonating detonator. We’re going to up the ante here a little.”
Darwin looked at Van Buren, startled. “Wait just a minute, Director. Unless I am mistaken, you are proposing to sell weapons to the Diatoms. Is that correct?”
      “I’m considering it,” Van Buren said. “Why?”
      “You’re familiar with the relevant statutes,” Darwin upbraided him. “That’s in direct contravention of several articles of the Reichenbach Charter.”
      The laws governing the sale of weapons to non-human cultures were strict and specific. They outlined in detail what technology could be sold, under what circumstances, and to whom. Given the enormous thrust of the weapons industry and the ready market for it it was necessary to regulate with great exactitude what was permissible and what was not. Van Buren, of course, was well aware of this.
      “I’m perhaps stretching the limits of the law a little,” Van Buren admitted. “Sometimes that’s necessary. Out here the law does not carry the same force that it does in the more settled parts of the galaxy. In a sense, it is we who determine what the law is – and what it is not.”
      Darwin shook his head. “The law, this law in particular, is not something you can twist and alter at your whim. You can not finesse it away and you can not plead special circumstances. There are very compelling reasons for a law such as this. Reasons of which you are well aware, Director.”
      “If I am not mistaken Darwin, your field of specialty is linguistics. I don’t recollect your being assigned as legal advisor to this mission. In fact,” Van Buren’s eyes shone with a hard light, “I am quite certain that function falls within my purview and not your own. If I wish your counsel on this matter I will invite it. I don’t appreciate it being offered gratuitously.”
      “I think you should know, Director,” Darwin stared back at Van Buren with equal determination, “that if you propose to go through with this my services will not be available. You will be on your own.”
      Van Buren’s face flooded with color. “I have your contract,” he said harshly. “If you violate the terms of that contract I shall have you expelled from the guild.”
      “And if you violate the terms of the Charter as you are proposing,” Darwin thrust his face forward, “I shall have you hauled before a tribunal and indicted.” Van Buren took a step forward, his fists clenched. The two men glared at one another.
      Ibid, forgotten all this while, directed a question at Darwin. The linguist glanced up, startled. It took him a moment to grasp what the Diatom had said.
      “What is it? What does he want?” Van Buren demanded.
      “He wishes to know . . . The man smoking the cigarette – he has never seen such a thing before.”
      “No?” Van Buren looked at the Diatom speculatively.       “Hollis, step up here for a minute. Let him see the cigarette.”
      Hollis stepped forward. He held the cigarette out so that the Diatom could examine it. The tip burned redly in the oxygen-rich atmosphere and a thin curl of smoke drifted up into the air. The Diatoms stared at it, fascinated.
      “All right now Hollis, smoke it. Demonstrate what it’s designed for.” Hollis took a drag on the cigarette, embarrassed by the unaccustomed attention. “Not like that, damn it!” Van Buren scowled. “This is a sales pitch! Make like you are in an ad back home. You want to convey an image of hipness and sophistication. The cigarette lends you an air of distinction and glamour you would never be able to achieve on your own.”
      Hollis immediately adopted a Jimmy Dean-type swagger. His lip curled in a defiant sneer. The cigarette dangled from the corner of his mouth, letting everyone know that he was not to be messed with, that he was one bad, hombre. The Diatoms clustered around him in open admiration, making inarticulate grunts of approval.
      “Do you see that, Darwin?” Van Buren declared triumphantly. “It was only a matter of time before we discovered a product that the Diatoms wanted. The first rule of any good salesman is: create a demand for what you are selling. It doesn’t matter whether your product is utterly frivolous and unnecessary – make them want it. Thus, the cigarette.” Hollis was totally into his role now as tobacco aficionado and when he blew a perfect smoke ring followed by another, smaller one, that barreled through the center of the first, the Diatoms actually began to dance around him, shouting their enthusiasm.
      “I’ll make a fortune,” Van Buren exclaimed to no one in particular. “Excise taxes. Import duties, a hundred percent mark up – Hell, why not two hundred percent?! I’ll bleed them white. I’ll fleece them of every nickel they ever owned and have them thanking me for the favor of doing so.”
      Darwin watched this spectacle with sad eyes, wishing to disassociate himself from the entire proceeding. He had entered into his career holding the highest of ideals, committed to spreading understanding and fostering sympathy and good will amongst different peoples. And what had he become – a pitchman for predatory capitalism, a purveyor of poisons and filth. He resembled one of those hucksters on late night Visiscreen, relentlessly hawking their products, appealing to the basest, most puerile instincts of their audience. And winning out – even as Van Buren was about to win out. A tiny flame of rebellion kindled in Darwin’s soul.
      When the negotiations resumed again he gave Van Buren a reassuring smile and nod. He spoke in a confident, winning fashion, employing all of his skills and knowledge of the Diatom tongue. “In my culture, amongst my people, cigarettes are renowned for two distinct features – nicotine and carcinogens. Let me explain.”
      Darwin set the match to the fuse and waited to see what would happen.

 

______

 

______